REPLIES TO THE CURRENT QUESTION
Our question last week was:
There is now widespread talk about "socializing" American institutions, like banks. What does the word "socialism" mean to you?
Here are your answers. The name of a writer is included only if he or she actually placed a name at the end of the message. Otherwise, we assume the writer wished anonymity and "name withheld" is inserted.
I'm not sure there is an existential component to the definition of socialism. Economics texts make it pretty clear: socialism is command directed economics whereby the state makes the key economic decisions as to what is being produced and how income is to be distributed; as opposed to capitalism which is a demand directed economics where the various players in the economy (consumers and producers) make the economic decisions and income is distributed based upon those independent transactions.
Of course, what we have in the West is neither fish nor fowl, but the "welfare state". All property is nominally in private hands. But, there is a significant government role in the decision making process in the form of tax policy and regulation. The welfare state straddles the continuum between capitalism and socialism. Up to now we have been on the capitalist side of the spectrum, as opposed to Europe which has been on the socialist side. With the advent of Obamaism we will end up on the socialist side. The American version of the welfare state will end up resembling the European model. And, that spells doom for American exceptionalism.
Capitalism requires risk and the animal spirits to confront and overcome those risks, knowing that whatever solution you come up with will present its own set of risks. With the feminization and infantilization of America we have produced a nation that has become risk adverse to the point that no amount of discomfort can be tolerated. Only in such a situation can a 7 year war with the amount of casualities that accumulated in a day during World War II be considered a failure despite the situation on the ground. Only in such a situation can an unemployment rate of 7% be considered catastophic when in the 1982 recession it was 10% and during the Great Depression (which is seems every recession is the greatest crisis since) when it was 25%. Only in an immasculated America can GM be considered too big to fail whereas in an earlier time GM would be considered too big not to be allowed to fail.
Alan Weick
When I was a kid, there were "Mom and Pop" grocery stores all over. The concept was reasonably sound. A small entrepreneur provided value by stocking the "stuff" that people wanted to buy. He/She knew what his customers wanted, got it from the wholesalers and delivered it at an appropriate mark-up. The size of the store restricted the variety and number of items they could adequately deliver but by astute market analysis they could deliver most of what the customers wanted. For lots of reasons, inefficiency probably being the most important, this American institution died away except in certain areas.
Now think of the Federal Government as Mom and Pop, running the "store". This is what socialism means to me, A single entity trying to select and deliver essential goods and services while also controlling the means and methods of providing those goods and services. For lots of reasons, inefficiency probably being the most important, Socialism has died away except in certain areas. The areas where it doesn't die away tend to be those where the people have lost their compass or where a strong central government/individual (read Dictator) ignores the broader needs of the people that exceed the capabilities of the central authority to deliver. So there is only one kind of ________(insert product or service), So what! Either like it or go without.
Don Newell
I have only an art degree... :-)... but here's my
definition of socialism:
Socialism is the belief that adult human beings
can live like children. Thus, politics should be designed
to embody the family values of...
brotherhood (my country is my family, and my fellow
citizens are my brothers and sisters),
faith (I will set aside my selfish desires and opinions
and immerse myself in the "will of the people" -- as
interpreted by my government's various branches,
bureaus and agencies),
family justice (I'm a member of this family, and I give
according to my ability, and receive according to my
need),
sharing (I will "spread the wealth" to my brothers and
sisters), and
love (we are all one big family, and I will accept and
embrace my diverse fellow citizens without reservation
or narrow-minded judgmentalism).
-Robert T.
|